FLOWERY BRANCH, Ga. — I am not going to lie, y'all. I was surprised when I pulled up some of your submissions for this week's Mailbox. I was fully expecting to see a handful of questions about the Falcons' defensive coordinator search. That's not really what I got.
Maybe its because the search is just getting started? Which, speaking of, you can follow along with all of the updates for said search right here on our defensive coordinator tracker. But I digress...
Your questions this week had a lot to do with roster construction and the way the Falcons account for certain players in their 2025 planning. So, let's get into it.
JC D. from Savannah
What is status of Bralen Trice and Demarcco Hellams? If they are OK and were worth drafting it is like having two free drafts picks cooking in. Why are they never mentioned?
Tori: They are never mentioned because they were never cleared to return to action during the 2024 season. There's really nothing more to say than that. There were thoughts towards the end of the season that maybe Hellams could come back, but that didn't end up panning out. So, there's that.
But also, I don't know what the 2025 season will hold for these two individuals once they are cleared. I can tell you the Falcons were hopeful about their 2024 seasons prior to their injuries. The coaching staff said a lot of good things about the two throughout training camp. They really liked the potential they saw. But can that potential be realized after a year away? How quickly can these two return to form? Or even impact the lineup? They both were well involved in the rotation leading into 2024, can they do so again in 2025?
There are just more questions than answers about Trice and Hellams at this point to feel confident one way or another about their potential impact.
David. H. from Marshalltown, Iowa
While the Falcons are on the hook for a lot of money for Kirk Cousins, I still think they are in good position. An experienced, solid backup and mentor for Penix for another season or a QB desperate team will inquire about a trade. Cousins, of course, will have a say in this. However, with him being a competitor and wanting to start in the NFL, there could be some leverage here for the Falcons to get a draft pick or player via trade and offset some debt. If you had to bet $5.00 on either scenario next season, which option do you most believe will happen?
Tori: First off, I am not a betting woman, David. But if I was (which I'm not lol) I would lean towards Cousins remaining on this roster in 2025, because its the easier scenario to accomplish. Hear me out.
I don't think it'll be as easy as some may think to work around Cousins' contract and the restraints it presents. Could there be a few teams hungry for a veteran quarterback this offseason? 100%, absolutely. But — and this is a big "but" — there are a lot of stars that have to align to make a move happen. For starters, and to your point, Cousins and his camp have to be OK with the move. He has to want to go to the place inquiring about him. With his no-trade clause, he holds power in this conversation, too. A lot of it. So, that's the first hurdle to jump through: Does Cousins want to go to X team?
If he does and waives his no-trade clause, the power then shifts back to the Falcons. What do they want for Cousins? And what is another team willing to give up for him? The Falcons should want draft capital. They lost a fifth-round pick in the tampering violation that included Cousins. And they sent a third rounder to New England for Matthew Judon. Draft capital would be important. As would offsetting how much money the Falcons would pay Cousins.
Without getting too in the weeds with contract talk, the best decision for the Falcons would be to trade Cousins after June 1 (in this hypothetical situation, of course). If that were the case, the Falcons would take on a dead money hit of $12.5 million with cap savings totaling $27.5 million, which is Cousins' guaranteed salary in 2025. Let's not even get into the fact that the team Cousins would hypothetically be traded to would have to take on his contract. Cousins is going to get paid, period. How are those funds allocated and is it worth it to the Falcons and Team X in question?
There are just so many variables in this discussion. So many hurdles to jump over. And in the end, is it worth it? Especially if the Falcons find themselves on the hook no matter what? That's why I tend to lean towards Cousins remaining on this roster in 2025. Call it the easy way out of answering the question, but its the path of least resistance. And it does make me feel better about the quarterback position if (God forbid) something happen to Michael Penix Jr.
But hey, my mind could always changed based on the right offer.
Michael S. from Calgary
You see a lot of GM's and coaches make short-term decisions for job security when they are on the hot seat - with questions about Terry Fontenot's job security, is there any concern of that here? I believe the formal term is a "lame duck season" and Falcons fans will be familiar with it as it took place right before we hired Terry.
Tori: That's always going to be a thought, Michael. You're talking about someone making decisions to save their job. This happens every year within multiple organizations. It's just the nature of things because as humans in this scenario, all you can realistically think about is getting through the next offseason if your seat is hot.
I will give it to Terry, though, he has always said the priority for him is building a "sustained winner." Now, have the Falcons done that yet? No. As Fontenot himself said, the Falcons have not won enough games during his tenure as general manager. But blowing things up is not realistic, and despite what some may think, I personally don't think things are as bad as they seem. I think the Falcons have work to do defensively, yes, but if Fontenot makes the right moves there? This thing could look and feel very difficult, without having to blow up the cap to do so. It helps that your would-be expensive playmakers like Drake London, Bijan Robinson and — now — Michael Penix Jr. are all on their rookie deals, too.
Join us as we take a look back on our favorite photos from the Atlanta Falcons' 2024-2025 season.